Red Dead Redemption 3: The Potential Protagonist & Narrative Innovations

red dead redemption 3
red dead redemption 3

As the gaming community buzzes with anticipation, the unannounced yet eagerly awaited Red Dead Redemption 3 remains a focal point of speculation.

The previous installments in the series not only set a benchmark for narrative depth but also garnered a massive following due to their compelling storytelling and dynamic characters.

While Rockstar Games has not officially revealed the game, the potential for continuing the saga of the Van Der Linde gang lingers in the air, ripe with possibilities.

Red Dead Redemption, with its blend of historical authenticity and rich narrative, has successfully captured the essence of the American frontier.

As we ponder the possibilities of a third installment, one can’t help but wonder about the direction Rockstar will take in terms of its protagonist and overarching storyline.

Could the father figure of the Van Der Linde gang, Hosea Matthews, carry the next chapter of this epic narrative? Or will the developers surprise us with another bold narrative choice?

This article dives deep into these questions, exploring potential story arcs and character developments that could define Red Dead Redemption 3.

Potential Protagonist: Hosea Matthews


Among the ensemble of characters in the Red Dead Redemption series, Hosea Matthews stands out not just for his wisdom and cunning but as a moral compass within the Van Der Linde gang.

A co-founder of the gang alongside Dutch Van Der Linde, Hosea has been an integral part of the narrative, providing depth and a counterbalance to Dutch’s increasingly erratic behavior.

As speculation about Red Dead Redemption 3 grows, considering Hosea as a protagonist offers a compelling new lens through which to view the series’ tumultuous world.

Key Attributes of Hosea Matthews:

  • Experienced and Wise: Hosea’s long history as an outlaw offers rich storytelling potential. His nuanced understanding of the changing American landscape at the turn of the century makes him a unique candidate to lead the narrative.
  • Moral Complexity: Unlike other gang members who often succumb totheir baser instincts, Hosea frequently demonstrates a preference for non-violence and strategy, making him a relatable and morally grey character.
  • Relationships and Influence: The dynamics between Hosea and other gang members, especially Dutch and Arthur Morgan, are pivotal. His mentorship roles and the impacts of his decisions can drive both the plot and character development forward in Red Dead Redemption 3.

Exploring Hosea’s early days, his eventual disillusionment with the outlaw life, and his critical role in the gang could serve as the central thread of the game.

His perspective would not only offer insights into the formative years of the Van Der Linde gang but also highlight the broader societal changes impacting the dying days of the Wild West.

Such a narrative would enrich the game’s historical context while providing continuity and freshness to the series’ storytelling approach.

Symbolic Elements: The Role of Hats

arthur morgan john marston goodbye red dead redemption 2
arthur morgan john marston goodbye red dead redemption 2

In the rich tapestry of Red Dead Redemption 2, subtle yet significant symbols abound, enhancing both the narrative depth and the player’s immersion in the story.

One of the most poignant of these symbols is the cowboy hat, an emblem not only of the era but also of the characters’ identities and transformations throughout the game.

The use of hats in Red Dead Redemption 2 serves as a narrative device that goes beyond mere aesthetic appeal, carrying weighty symbolic significance.

The Symbolic Significance of Arthur Morgan’s Hat:

  • Identity and Legacy: Arthur’s hat is more than just headwear; it represents his identity and the legacy he leaves behind. The moment when Arthur passes his hat to John Marston symbolizes the transfer of the protagonist role and foreshadows John’s future journey.
  • Narrative Continuity and Transition: This passing of the hat marks a pivotal narrative transition in the game, serving as both an emotional and symbolic handover from one chapter to the next.

Looking ahead to Red Dead Redemption 3, the symbolic role of hats could be expanded even further. Imagining Hosea’s storyline, the presence or absence of his hat in key scenes could signify major emotional or moral shifts.

For instance, moments when Hosea chooses not to wear his hat could be used to emphasize his detachment from his outlaw identity or his reflective moments of moral clarity.

Incorporating these symbolic elements into the gameplay and narrative structure not only enriches the story but also engages players on a deeper psychological level, making their gaming experience more meaningful and memorable.

Game Setting and Historical Context

The setting of Red Dead Redemption 2, centered around the close of the 19th century, plays a crucial role in shaping the narrative and the characters within it.

As we speculate on the possibilities for Red Dead Redemption 3, understanding the historical backdrop and its influence on the game’s direction is vital.

Key Historical Influences on the Game:

  • End of the Wild West Era: The game is set during a time when the American frontier was closing, and modern age was beginning to take shape. This transition from lawlessness to order shapes the existential crises of the characters, who struggle to find their place in an evolving world.
  • Technological and Social Changes: The late 19th century was marked by significant technological advancements such as the expansion of the railway system and the advent of the Industrial Revolution. These changes can be used to drive conflicts and plot developments in Red Dead Redemption 3, reflecting the tensions between the old ways of the rugged outlaws and the new societal norms.

Considering Hosea Matthews as a protagonist could allow the narrative to delve into an earlier timeline, perhaps in the mid-1800s, offering a fresh perspective on the events leading up to those depicted in Red Dead Redemption 2. This prequel approach could explore:

  • Formative Events: Key events that shaped the ethos of the Van Der Linde gang and their initial reactions to the encroaching changes of modernity.
  • Early Relationships: The dynamics between younger versions of characters like Dutch, Hosea, and Arthur, providing a deeper historical context to their actions and decisions in later games.

Exploring these historical nuances would not only enhance the narrative depth but also provide a richer, more immersive gaming experience that educates as well as entertains.

This historical layering could also serve to anchor the game’s events within a broader socio-political narrative, adding a layer of realism and relevance to the players’ experiences.

Narrative Traditions and Innovations

Red Dead Redemption is a series celebrated for its deep, multi-layered storytelling and strong character development. Over the iterations, Rockstar Games has skillfully employed multiple protagonists to enhance the narrative’s breadth and depth.

This tradition of shifting perspectives has allowed players to explore complex storylines from different vantage points, enriching the overall gaming experience.

The Use of Multiple Protagonists:

  • John Marston and Arthur Morgan: The switch between John and Arthur in the previous games provided varied storytelling perspectives, making each protagonist’s journey feel unique yet interconnected.
  • Narrative Depth: This approach has allowed the games to delve deeper into the emotional and moral complexities of the characters, reflecting the tumultuous changes of the era and their personal impacts.

As speculation about RedDead Redemption 3 continues, it raises questions about whether this narrative device will be maintained or if Rockstar might innovate further.

Considering the series’ history and the potential closure of the overarching plot, the next installment could:

  • End the Protagonist Merry-Go-Round: While the switching of main characters has been a hallmark of the series, there might be a creative pivot to focus on a single protagonist’s narrative arc to provide a more concentrated and poignant conclusion to the saga.
  • Enhance Player Connection: Focusing on one protagonist, possibly Hosea Matthews, could allow for a deeper emotional investment from the player, providing a continuous and immersive narrative experience from start to finish.

Furthermore, incorporating innovative narrative techniques such as non-linear storytelling or multiple outcome scenarios based on player choices could redefine the way stories are told in the series.

These innovations would not only keep the gameplay fresh but also align with the evolving expectations of the gaming community.

Impact of Rockstar’s Other Projects

Rockstar Games is known not just for the Red Dead Redemption series but also for other monumental titles like Grand Theft Auto.

With the upcoming release of Grand Theft Auto 6, it’s essential to consider how Rockstar’s focus on such a significant project might influence the development and strategic rollout of Red Dead Redemption 3.

Factors Influencing Development:

  • Resource Allocation: The development of a major title like Grand Theft Auto 6 could require significant company resources, potentially impacting the timeline and focus dedicated to Red Dead Redemption 3. Managing two massive projects simultaneously could challenge Rockstar but also showcases their capability to push boundaries in the gaming industry.
  • Market Strategy: Rockstar might strategically space the release of both games to maximize market impact and avoid competition between their own titles. This strategy could affect the development pace and marketing campaigns for Red Dead Redemption 3.

Potential Benefits:

  • Technology and Innovation Transfer: Advances made during the development of Grand Theft Auto 6 could be beneficial for Red Dead Redemption 3. This includes enhancements in game mechanics, graphics, and narrative techniques that could be cross-applied to enrich the gaming experience.
  • Increased Anticipation and Hype: The success of Rockstar’s projects tends to build anticipation for their other games. The launch of Grand Theft Auto 6 could serve to heighten interest and expectations for Red Dead Redemption 3, potentially boosting its reception and success.

Rockstar’s reputation for producing high-quality, deeply engaging games suggests that despite the challenges, the development of Red Dead Redemption 3 could benefit from the company’s ongoing projects.

The synergy between multiple high-stakes projects could propel Rockstar to new heights of creative and technical achievement.

Related Post: Red Dead Redemption 3 Has to Hit the Same Highs but Also the Same Lows as RDR2


As the gaming community continues to speculate and buzz with anticipation, the potential development of Red Dead Redemption 3 represents a significant milestone in narrative gaming.

With Hosea Matthews rumored as a potential protagonist, the game could offer a fresh yet familiar perspective on the evolving American frontier, enriching the series’ already profound narrative depth.

The symbolic elements, historical setting, and narrative traditions discussed provide a framework for what could be another epic tale of loyalty, morality, and survival in the face of inevitable change.

While Rockstar Games juggles other major projects like Grand Theft Auto 6, the lessons and technologies from these endeavors could significantly enhance the development of Red Dead Redemption 3.

For fans and newcomers alike, the anticipation of Hosea’s story offers a promising new chapter in the Red Dead Redemption saga.

Whether continuing the tradition of multiple protagonists or focusing on a single, detailed narrative arc, Rockstar’s next move will undoubtedly be a benchmark in gaming history.

As we await official announcements, the speculation itself keeps the spirit of the Wild West alive and thriving in the hearts of gamers worldwide.